Tradition Timeline Leave an objection

Start page / Objections / Authority

“Popes have been heretics. Liberius signed an Arian creed, a council anathematized Honorius, and John XXII preached error on the beatific vision. So the papacy cannot be what the Catholic Church says it is, and a pope today can be a heretic too.”

Verses cited for this objection: Luke 22:31-32, Gal. 2:11

Each mark is one quotation. Touch the timeline to read it.

Short answer

The Church does not teach that every pope is sinless or right in everything he says. Liberius gave way under exile and threat, a general council anathematized Honorius, and Benedict XII defined when the souls of the just see God. The Church claims a gift for the pope when he defines a doctrine of faith for the whole Church, and she defines heresy as obstinate denial of a truth of faith. The Church has made no such judgment of any recent pope, and this timeline shows the measure by which the earlier cases were judged.

Where it starts with Jesus

At the Last Supper Jesus tells Peter that Satan has demanded to sift him, that he has prayed for him that his faith may not fail, and that Peter is to strengthen his brethren after he has turned again.

““Simon, Simon, behold, Satan demanded to have you, that he might sift you like wheat, but I have prayed for you that your faith may not fail; and when you have turned again, strengthen your brethren.””

JesusLuke 22:31-32Read it in the source: Bible Gateway, RSV Catholic Edition

How it points to Jesus

The prayer is Christ's, and the next verses of the same passage record Peter's three denials. The Church does not claim that the popes cannot fall. She points to the prayer of Jesus for Peter's faith and to the task he gave Peter. Every pope is held to what Christ taught, and every case in this timeline is judged by it.

Drafted from primary sources. Every quotation is checked against the page it links to. The text of John XXII's own retraction and the text of Honorius's own letter to Sergius could not be found on an approved host, so neither is quoted.

14 quotations in date order

A work in progress. The quotations below are not all the evidence on this matter. More are being added.

The Old Testamentbefore Christ
Old TestamentA seated old man in a red robe and blue scarf turns sharply, holding a scroll, with his open hand stretched out
Scripture
The prophet Ezekiel Ezekiel 34:2

“Ho, shepherds of Israel who have been feeding yourselves! Should not shepherds feed the sheep?”

Read it in the source: Bible Gateway, RSV Catholic Edition

c. AD 30
Scripture
Jesus to the crowds and his disciples Matthew 23:2-3

“The scribes and the Pharisees sit on Moses’ seat; so practice and observe whatever they tell you, but not what they do; for they preach, but do not practice.”

Read it in the source: Bible Gateway, RSV Catholic Edition

c. AD 30Christ at the centre of a long table raises a white host, with the twelve apostles leaning towards him on either side
Scripture
Jesus at the Last Supper Luke 22:32-34

“…I have prayed for you that your faith may not fail; and when you have turned again, strengthen your brethren.” And he said to him, “Lord, I am ready to go with you to prison and to death.” He said, “I tell you, Peter, the cock will not crow this day, until you three times deny that you know me.””

Read it in the source: Bible Gateway, RSV Catholic Edition

c. 50-55A bald, bearded apostle in a red cloak over a blue tunic, holding a folded letter in one hand and resting the other on a long sword
Scripture
St. Paul Galatians 2:11, 14

“…I opposed him to his face, because he stood condemned. … But when I saw that they were not straightforward about the truth of the gospel, I said to Cephas before them all, “If you, though a Jew, live like a Gentile and not like a Jew, how can you compel the Gentiles to live like Jews?””

Read it in the source: Bible Gateway, RSV Catholic Edition

c. 355
Church Father
Theodoret of Cyrus, reporting the exchange between Liberius and Constantius Ecclesiastical History 2.13

“I have already taken leave of the brethren who are in that city. The decrees of the Church are of greater importance than a residence in Rome. … Neither three days nor three months can change my sentiments. Send me wherever you please.”

Read it in the source: New Advent

c. 357A worn icon of a bishop with a broad grey beard holding a jewelled book, on a red and gold ground
Church Father
St. Athanasius History of the Arians, Part V, 41

“But Liberius after he had been in banishment two years gave way, and from fear of threatened death subscribed. Yet even this only shows their violent conduct, and the hatred of Liberius against the heresy, and his support of Athanasius, so long as he was suffered to exercise a free choice.”

Read it in the source: New Advent

681
Council

Third Council of Constantinople: Pope Honorius anathematized

Third Council of Constantinople Session XIII, the sentence against the Monothelites

“…as well as the letter of the latter [Honorius] to the same Sergius, we find that these documents are quite foreign to the apostolic dogmas, to the declarations of the holy Councils, and to all the accepted Fathers, and that they follow the false teachings of the heretics; therefore we entirely reject them, and execrate them as hurtful to the soul. … And with these we define that there shall be expelled from the holy Church of God and anathematized Honorius who was some time Pope of Old Rome, because of what we found written by him to Sergius, that in all respects he followed his view and confirmed his impious doctrines.”

Read it in the source: New Advent

The Middle Ages800 to 1500
c. 1271A Dominican friar with a tonsure and a gold halo holds an open book and a small church, with a shining sun on his chest
Doctor of the Church
St. Thomas Aquinas Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 11, a. 1, I answer that

“Secondly, because, though he intends to assent to Christ, yet he fails in his choice of those things wherein he assents to Christ, because he chooses not what Christ really taught, but the suggestions of his own mind. Therefore heresy is a species of unbelief, belonging to those who profess the Christian faith, but corrupt its dogmas.”

Read it in the source: New Advent

1336
Magisterium
Pope Benedict XII Apostolic Constitution Benedictus Deus (1336)

“By this Constitution which is to remain in force for ever, we, with apostolic authority, define the following: According to the general disposition of God, the souls of all the saints who departed from this world before the passion of our Lord Jesus Christ … Since the passion and death of the Lord Jesus Christ, these souls have seen and see the divine essence with an intuitive vision and even face to face”

Read it in the source: EWTN Library

The Modern Era1800 to today
1870A black and white engraving of hundreds of bishops seated in tiers on either side of a hall, with the pope enthroned at the far end
Council
First Vatican Council Pastor Aeternus, ch. 4

“The Roman pontiffs, too, … defined as doctrines to be held those things which, by God’s help, they knew to be in keeping with sacred scripture and the apostolic traditions.”

Read it in the source: Papal Encyclicals Online

1870
Council
First Vatican Council Pastor Aeternus, ch. 4

“This gift of truth and never-failing faith was therefore divinely conferred on Peter and his successors in this see so that they might discharge their exalted office for the salvation of all, and so that the whole flock of Christ might be kept away by them from the poisonous food of error and be nourished with the sustenance of heavenly doctrine.”

Read it in the source: Papal Encyclicals Online

1992
Magisterium
Catechism of the Catholic Church CCC 553

“Jesus, the Good Shepherd, confirmed this mandate after his Resurrection: "Feed my sheep."”

Read it in the source: vatican.va

1992
Magisterium
Catechism of the Catholic Church CCC 881

“The Lord made Simon alone, whom he named Peter, the "rock" of his Church. He gave him the keys of his Church and instituted him shepherd of the whole flock.”

Read it in the source: vatican.va

1992
Magisterium
Catechism of the Catholic Church CCC 2089

“"Heresy is the obstinate post-baptismal denial of some truth which must be believed with divine and catholic faith, or it is likewise an obstinate doubt concerning the same; apostasy is the total repudiation of the Christian faith; schism is the refusal of submission to the Roman Pontiff or of communion with the members of the Church subject to him."”

Read it in the source: vatican.va

Related timelines

Peter the rock“The rock in Matthew 16:18 is Christ, or Peter's confession of faith. It is not Peter. Scripture says Christ is the only foundation and the head of the Church.”18 quotations, from the Old Testament to 1992The office of Peter“Peter had no special office over the Apostles, and his authority is not passed to successors, specifically to the bishops of Rome.”20 quotations, from the Old Testament to 1992Papal supremacy“Peter had no authority over the other apostles, and the Pope has none over the whole Church. James presided at the council in Jerusalem, and Peter calls himself only a fellow elder.”18 quotations, from the Old Testament to 2025Papal infallibility“The Pope cannot be infallible. Jesus rebuked Peter and called him Satan, and Paul had to oppose him to his face at Antioch.”17 quotations, from the Old Testament to 1992The tradition of the papacyThis timeline follows the office of the pope from its root in Scripture to today. It begins long before anything was defined: what Jesus said to Peter, what the early writers say of Peter's preaching and death at Rome, how the first Christians spoke of the church of Rome, when other churches turned to it and when they resisted it. It then shows how Rome and Constantinople came to give different accounts of Rome's place, down to the break of 1054, and how the office was defined afterward, at Florence in 1439 and in full at the First Vatican Council in 1870.57 quotations, from the Old Testament to 25 May 1995All the popes in order, from St. Peter to todayThis page gives every pope in order, from the apostle Peter to the present pope, as the list published by the Holy See gives them. Under the list are quotations from each age of the Church. Some name the bishops of Rome one after another, and some say how one pope follows the last.15 quotations, from the Old Testament to 18 May 2025