Tradition Timeline Leave an objection

Start page / Objections / Salvation

“The Catholic Church sold forgiveness of sins for money, and still teaches that indulgences can buy your way out of punishment. Indulgences have no basis in Scripture.”

Verses cited for this objection: Acts 8:18-20, Eph. 2:8-9, Heb. 10:14

Each mark is one quotation. Touch the timeline to read it.
A worn wall painting of a pope in a tall tiara at a balcony hung with a patterned cloth, between two attendants
Pope Boniface VIII proclaims the Jubilee of 1300, the first Holy Year: what remains of a fresco in the basilica of St. John Lateran in Rome. Fresco: attributed to Giotto, about 1300, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Resized.

Short answer

An indulgence does not forgive sin. It is a remission of the temporal punishment that remains for sins whose guilt has already been forgiven, and Aquinas says true contrition and confession are required to gain one. The Church grants it by the power to bind and loose that Christ gave her, and the bishops of the early centuries used that power to shorten penances. Abuses did happen. The Fourth Lateran Council, the Council of Trent and Pope Paul VI all say so, and Trent abolished the office of the alms collectors and ordered every evil gain connected with indulgences to be abolished.

Where it starts with Jesus

Jesus gives his disciples the power to bind and to loose, and says that heaven will hold to what they bind and loose on earth.

“Truly, I say to you, whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.”

JesusMatthew 18:18Read it in the source: Bible Gateway, RSV Catholic Edition

How it points to Jesus

An indulgence is an act of that power. It forgives no sin. It is given only to someone who has already repented and been forgiven, and it rests wholly on what Christ won on the cross.

Drafted from primary sources. Every quotation is checked against the page it links to.

19 quotations in date order

A work in progress. The quotations below are not all the evidence on this matter. More are being added.

The Old Testamentbefore Christ
Old TestamentA bearded king in a crown and an ermine-trimmed robe looks upward as he plays a harp
Scripture
The prophet Nathan to King David 2 Samuel 12:13-14

“David said to Nathan, “I have sinned against the Lord.” And Nathan said to David, “The Lord also has put away your sin; you shall not die. Nevertheless, because by this deed you have utterly scorned the Lord, the child that is born to you shall die.””

Read it in the source: Bible Gateway, RSV Catholic Edition

Old Testament
Scripture
The Book of Tobit Tobit 12:8-9

“Prayer is good when accompanied by fasting, almsgiving, and righteousness. … For almsgiving delivers from death, and it will purge away every sin.”

Read it in the source: Bible Gateway, RSV Catholic Edition

c. AD 30An ancient painted icon of Christ with a dark beard and a gold halo, his right hand raised in blessing and a jewelled book of the Gospels in his left
Scripture
Jesus to the disciples Matthew 18:18

“Truly, I say to you, whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.”

Read it in the source: Bible Gateway, RSV Catholic Edition

c. AD 35A dark-haired, bearded man in a green robe with a white collar, his head tilted, looking out at the viewer
Scripture
St. Luke, on Simon the magician and St. Peter Acts 8:18-20

“Now when Simon saw that the Spirit was given through the laying on of the apostles’ hands, he offered them money, saying, “Give me also this power, that any one on whom I lay my hands may receive the Holy Spirit.” But Peter said to him, “Your silver perish with you, because you thought you could obtain the gift of God with money!”

Read it in the source: Bible Gateway, RSV Catholic Edition

c. AD 56A bald, bearded apostle in a red cloak over a blue tunic, holding a folded letter in one hand and resting the other on a long sword
Scripture
St. Paul 2 Corinthians 2:6-7, 10

“For such a one this punishment by the majority is enough; so you should rather turn to forgive and comfort him, or he may be overwhelmed by excessive sorrow. … Any one whom you forgive, I also forgive. What I have forgiven, if I have forgiven anything, has been for your sake in the presence of Christ”

Read it in the source: Bible Gateway, RSV Catholic Edition

c. AD 61
Scripture
St. Paul Colossians 1:24

“Now I rejoice in my sufferings for your sake, and in my flesh I complete what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions for the sake of his body, that is, the church”

Read it in the source: Bible Gateway, RSV Catholic Edition

c. 197An engraving of a bearded man in a turban holding a scroll, set in a page of printed French text
Church Father
Tertullian To the Martyrs, ch. 1

“Some, not able to find this peace in the Church, have been used to seek it from the imprisoned martyrs. And so you ought to have it dwelling with you, and to cherish it, and to guard it, that you may be able perhaps to bestow it upon others.”

Read it in the source: New Advent

250An engraving of a bearded man in robes holding an open book, standing like a statue in a niche, with a small scene in a landscape on the base below
Church Father
St. Cyprian of Carthage Epistle 12, 1

“…they who have received certificates from the martyrs, and may be assisted by their privilege with God, if they should be seized with any misfortune and peril of sickness, should, without waiting for my presence, before any presbyter who might be present, or if a presbyter should not be found and death begins to be imminent, before even a deacon, be able to make confession of their sin, that, with the imposition of hands upon them for repentance, they should come to the Lord with the peace which the martyrs have desired, by their letters to us, to be granted to them.”

Read it in the source: New Advent

325A crowded icon of haloed bishops in bright vestments seated in rows around a throne that holds an open book
Council
First Council of Nicaea Canon 12

“In every case, however, their disposition and the nature of their penitence should be examined. For those who through their fear and tears and perseverance and good works give evidence of their conversion by deeds and not by outward show, when they have completed their appointed term as hearers, may properly take part in the prayers, and the bishop is competent to decide even more favourably in their regard. But those who have taken the matter lightly, and have thought that the outward form of entering the church is all that is required for their conversion, must complete their term to the full.”

Read it in the source: Papal Encyclicals Online

The Middle Ages800 to 1500
1215A medieval wall painting of a young beardless pope in a tall pointed tiara and a pallium marked with crosses
Council
Fourth Lateran Council Constitution 62

“Let those who are sent to seek alms be modest and discreet, and let them not stay in taverns or other unsuitable places or incur useless or excessive expenses, being careful above all not to wear the garb of false religion. Moreover, because the keys of the church are brought into contempt and satisfaction through penance loses its force through indiscriminate and excessive indulgences, which certain prelates of churches do not fear to grant, we therefore decree that when a basilica is dedicated, the indulgence shall not be for more than one year”

Read it in the source: Papal Encyclicals Online

c. 1256A Dominican friar with a tonsure and a gold halo holds an open book and a small church, with a shining sun on his chest
Doctor of the Church
St. Thomas Aquinas Summa Theologiae, Supplement, q. 25, a. 1, I answer that

“Hence we must say on the contrary that indulgences hold good both in the Church's court and in the judgment of God, for the remission of the punishment which remains after contrition, absolution, and confession, whether this punishment be enjoined or not. The reason why they so avail is the oneness of the mystical body in which many have performed works of satisfaction exceeding the requirements of their debts”

Read it in the source: New Advent

c. 1256
Doctor of the Church
St. Thomas Aquinas Summa Theologiae, Supplement, q. 27, a. 1, I answer that

“…although those merits which are applied by means of an indulgence, might possibly avail a person so that he could merit grace (by way of congruity and impetration), yet it is not for this reason that they are applied, but for the remission of punishment. Hence they do not avail those who are in mortal sin, and consequently, true contrition and confession are demanded as conditions for gaining all indulgences.”

Read it in the source: New Advent

1551Rows of bishops in mitres sit in a great semicircle of benches inside a church, facing the presiding cardinals
Council
Council of Trent Session 14, On the Sacrament of Penance, ch. 8

“But neither is this satisfaction, which we discharge for our sins, so our own, as not to be through Jesus Christ. For we who can do nothing of ourselves, as of ourselves, can do all things, He cooperating, who strengthens us. Thus, man has not wherein to glory, but all our glorying is in Christ: in whom we live; in whom we merit; in whom we satisfy; bringing forth fruits worthy of penance, which from him have their efficacy; by him are offered to the Father; and through him are accepted by the Father.”

Read it in the source: Papal Encyclicals Online

1562
Council
Council of Trent Session 21, Decree on Reformation, ch. 9

“Whereas many remedies, heretofore applied by divers councils in their day, as well by that of Lateran, and of Lyons, as by that of Vienne, against the wicked abuses of questors of alms, have become in later times useless; yea, rather the depravity of such is, to the great scandal and complaint of all the faithful, found daily so to increase the more, as that there seems to be no longer any hope left of their amendment; (the Synod) ordains that, in all parts of Christendom soever, their name and use be henceforth utterly abolished … that so all men may at length truly understand, that these heavenly treasures of the Church are administered, not for gain, but for godliness.”

Read it in the source: Papal Encyclicals Online

1563
Council
Council of Trent Session 25, Decree Concerning Indulgences

“Whereas the power of conferring Indulgences was granted by Christ to the Church; and she has, even in the most ancient times, used the said power, delivered unto her of God … And being desirous that the abuses which have crept therein, and by occasion of which this honourable name of Indulgences is blasphemed by heretics, be amended and corrected, It ordains generally by this decree, that all evil gains for the obtaining thereof, whence a most prolific cause of abuses amongst the Christian people has been derived, be wholly abolished.”

Read it in the source: Papal Encyclicals Online

The Modern Era1800 to today
1967A colour photograph of a pope in a red cape trimmed with white fur and an embroidered stole
Magisterium
Pope St. Paul VI Indulgentiarum Doctrina, 8

“Unfortunately, the practice of indulgences has at times been improperly used either through "untimely and superfluous indulgences" by which the power of the keys was humiliated and penitential satisfaction weakened, or through the collection of "illicit profits" by which indulgences were blasphemously defamed. But the Church, in deploring and correcting these improper uses "teaches and establishes that the use of indulgences must be preserved because it is supremely salutary for the Christian people and authoritatively approved by the sacred councils…"”

Read it in the source: vatican.va

1992
Magisterium
Catechism of the Catholic Church CCC 1434

“Scripture and the Fathers insist above all on three forms, fasting, prayer, and almsgiving, which express conversion in relation to oneself, to God, and to others. Alongside the radical purification brought about by Baptism or martyrdom they cite as means of obtaining forgiveness of sins: effort at reconciliation with one's neighbor, tears of repentance, concern for the salvation of one's neighbor, the intercession of the saints, and the practice of charity "which covers a multitude of sins."”

Read it in the source: vatican.va

1992
Magisterium
Catechism of the Catholic Church CCC 1471, 1478

“An indulgence is a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven, which the faithful Christian who is duly disposed gains under certain prescribed conditions through the action of the Church … An indulgence is obtained through the Church who, by virtue of the power of binding and loosing granted her by Christ Jesus, intervenes in favor of individual Christians and opens for them the treasury of the merits of Christ and the saints to obtain from the Father of mercies the remission of the temporal punishments due for their sins.”

Read it in the source: vatican.va

1992
Magisterium
Catechism of the Catholic Church CCC 1473

“The forgiveness of sin and restoration of communion with God entail the remission of the eternal punishment of sin, but temporal punishment of sin remains.”

Read it in the source: vatican.va

Related timelines

ProtestantismIn 1517 Martin Luther published ninety-five theses on indulgences. This timeline begins with what led up to them: an old abuse that a council had warned against, Luther's years as an Augustinian friar and the struggle of conscience he describes, what he was writing before indulgences came up, and the indulgence preached for the building of St. Peter's. It then gives the theses, the Church's reply, what the Church later said had been wrong, and the reforms the Council of Trent made. After that it follows the teachings that set Protestants apart from the Catholic Church as each one is put forward. It also shows, step by step, how the Reformers and their confessions came to set seven books of the Old Testament outside the canon. Each of those entries links to the earliest witness on this site to what the Church already taught on that point, and to the full Catholic answer. It ends with how far the Protestant bodies came to differ among themselves, and with what each says today about how a person is saved, in the words of its own confession.93 quotations, from the Old Testament to TodayPurgatory“Purgatory is not in the Bible. Jesus told the thief he would be with him in Paradise that day, and Paul says that to be away from the body is to be at home with the Lord.”17 quotations, from the Old Testament to 2007Penance and ReconciliationPenance, also called Reconciliation or Confession, is the sacrament in which the Church, in the Lord's name, forgives sins committed after Baptism. This timeline starts with Christ forgiving sins and giving the apostles that power. It then shows how the Church dealt with grave sin in the first centuries, by a public penance that was often allowed only once, how private and repeated confession became the usual form, and what the councils, a Doctor and the popes have said about it since.20 quotations, from the Old Testament to 1992Confession to a priest“We don't need to confess our sins to a priest. Christ is the one mediator, the veil was torn, and we can go straight to God for forgiveness.”20 quotations, from the Old Testament to 1992Faith and works“Catholics say you are saved by grace at first, but after that you have to keep yourself saved by your own works. Scripture says we are justified by faith apart from works.”19 quotations, from the Old Testament to 2008Praying to saints“Praying to saints is talking to the dead, which God forbids as necromancy. Jesus taught us to pray to the Father, and there is one mediator between God and men.”18 quotations, from the Old Testament to 1992